The Sky's the limit? |
But do they work for trade marks?
This question has been indirectly considered in two recent English cases: Karen Millen v Karen Millen Fashions Ltd and Skyscape Cloud Services Ltd v Sky Plc.
The background to both cases is different.
Skyscape supplies cloud computer services to organisations within the UK public sector. Sky, the broadcaster, barely needs an introduction. Sky alleged infringement of some of its trade marks and Skyscape offered limited undertakings in return. Although Sky did not issue proceedings, Skyscape opted to commence proceedings against Sky in order to gain “commercial certainty regarding the conduct of their business” [6].
The Karen Millen dispute has a more complicated backstory concerning what rights were and were not transferred with the sale of a business. One of the reasons for Karen Millen (the individual) bringing the claim was a desire to return to retail with a clearer understanding of the extent to which she could use her name. As the judge put it, “at the heart of this dispute… is the range of negative declarations sought by [Karen Millen] to establish what she can do, before she starts to trade” [255].
What's in a name? |
Unlike patents, English trade mark legislation does not expressly provide for declarations of non-infringement but they are possible provided that the following principles have been established:
- The question of whether to grant negative declarations is one of discretion rather than jurisdiction.
- The use of negative declarations should be scrutinised and their use rejected where it would serve no useful purpose, but where such a declaration would help ensure that the aims of justice were achieved, the court should not be reluctant to grant a negative declaration.
- Before a court can properly make a negative declaration, the underlying issue must be sufficiently clearly defined.
My kind of skyscape |
Skyscape was asking for a DNI in relation to each of (i) SKYSCAPE and (ii) SKYSCAPE CLOUD SERVICES in various fonts, colours and letter case as well as (iii) 18 logos in connection with 10 types of service and the provision of services enabling transition to each of those services. Although the basic question was whether it was ok for Skyscape to use SKYSCAPE in connection with cloud computing for the public sector in the UK, there were a lot of theoretical combinations for each name or logo and service.
Skyscape attempted to deal with these concerns by grouping the marks together and identifying goods or services which Sky had highlighted as a particular concern. This was provided too late in the proceedings (mid trial) to be of use to the court but could conceivably be an approach used by litigants in the future provided that any such table also deals with the question of identity/similarity in the signs as well and the question is dealt with before (or at least at) the case management conference.
Another favourite skyscape |
One of the big difficulties identified by Richard Meade in Karen Millen was that because the Claimant hadn't yet launched her business, it was not possible to precisely compare the goods and services. As he put it:
"There is no statement about where or how [the Claimant's business] would trade, its trade dress, or which of the various marks would actually be used, separately or in combination. For example, ...[i]t seems to me that it could make a very great difference to my assessment of the likelihood of confusion if the Claimant were to use KAREN on women's clothes, and KAREN MILLEN on perfume, candles and eyewear."So, is it worth bringing proceedings for a declaration of non-infringement?
As always, it depends on the particular circumstances, and there may well be situations where a threat of trade mark proceedings is too great a risk for a business to continue to trade. Should a claimant decide to go down this road in the future, these cases give a useful indication of the extent to which a declaration will be granted and the evidence the court will look for when making its assessment.
I am very curious about a Career in Company Secretaryship. For me understanding Why I want to choose a Career in Company Secretaryship is phenomenally more important than figuring out How to get into Company Secretaryship. In my quest to learn more about a Career in Company Secretaryship, I found this amazing page: https://www.lifepage.in/career/20171002-0002/Commerce/Company Secretaryship/Career-in-Company-Secretaryship/hindi
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteis it safe to buy cannabis oil online
can you buy cannabis vape oil online
buy cannabis online pei
buy cannabis shatter online
lyrics high school diploma buy my new album hungry
where can you buy homeschool high school diploma
can i buy a fake high school diploma
where can i buy a legit high school diploma
where to buy fake high school diploma
buy accredited high school diploma online
high school diploma to buy
cannabis buy online canada
buy cannabis online gatineau
nembutal euthanasia
purchasing nembutal online
how to make nembutal at home
purchase nembutal
order nembutal
buy cannabis online eu
buy medicinal cannabis online queens
cannabis seeds buy online india
where buy cannabis online
passion dolls
mini love doll
anime sex toy
life size dolls
sould i buy the air ticket with green card or passport name
buy xanax online legally cheap
buy gun parts with bitcoin
buy gun online with bitcoin
buy medicinal cannabis online maryland
588poker
ReplyDeleteJagadpoker
centralqq
hebatqq
Daftar 99dewa
ReplyDeletemadu99 link alternatif
Link Central
dewa poker 88
arena99 link alternatif
wedeqq apk
To be honest I found very helpful information your blog thanks for providing us such blog cricket prediction
ReplyDeleteThis is Brother Error Code ts-02 and Brother Printer Error Code ts-02 as well this is best type of Brother Printer Code ts-02 and last one that is all about Brother Printer Error ts-02 and last one Brother Printer Error Code ts-02
ReplyDelete"This is Canon Error Code 1007 and Canon Printer Error Code 1007 as well this is best type of Canon Printer Error Code 1007 and last one that is all about Canon Error Code 1007 and last one Canon Error Code 1007 "
ReplyDelete"This is Canon Error Code E04 and Canon Printer Error Code E04 as well this is best type of Canon Printer Error Code E04 and last one that is all about Canon Error Code E04 and last one Canon Error Code E04 "
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteThis is epson printer error code 0xe5 is epson error code 0xe5 and also
epson printer error 0xe5
This is epson printer error code 0xea and also epson error code 0xea
This is epson printer error code 0xf3 and epson error code 0xf3
ReplyDeleteThis is Epson Printer Error Code 00044 | epson error 000044 and
epson printer error 000044
This is Epson Printer Error Code 1073 and Epson Error Code 1073
This is epson printer error code e-2 | epson error code e-2 and
epson error e-2
Hey, I was read your blog and you write some great benefits of freelancer. When I was read your blog it was too good for HR departments who hiring Freelance Content Writer In Delhi.
ReplyDeleteFreelance Content Writer in Delhi